What Are Land Disputes? The Types Of Land Disputes

Land is a crucial asset that holds significant importance for both individuals and the nation as a whole. In recent times, numerous instances of land disputes have emerged, involving conflicts between individuals or between individuals and governing bodies or organizations responsible for safeguarding land ownership or usage rights. To gain a comprehensive understanding of land disputes, we turn to NT INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM‘s informative article below.

What are land disputes?

Legal Basis:

• Circular 14/2012/TT-BTNMT: Defines the concept of “land” as an area with a specific location, boundaries, and area. The circular also recognizes that land attributes may be stable or changeable, but exhibit cyclical and predictable patterns. These attributes are influenced by various factors such as soil, terrain, climate, and human activity.
• 2013 Land Law: Defines “land dispute” in Clause 24, Article 3 as a disagreement between two or more parties regarding their rights, obligations, and legal interests related to land use.

Definition:

A land dispute arises when two or more parties disagree about their rights, obligations, or legal interests concerning land use. This disagreement can involve issues such as:

• Land ownership: Who owns the land?
• Land use rights: Who has the right to use the land and for what purposes?
• Boundaries: Where are the boundaries of the land?
• Compensation: How much compensation is due to a party for the use of their land or for any harm caused to their land?

Types of Land Disputes:

• Boundary disputes: disagreements about the location of land boundaries.
• Ownership disputes: disagreements about who owns the land.
• Use rights disputes: disagreements about who has the right to use the land and for what purposes.
• Inheritance disputes: disagreements about who inherits land rights.
• Compensation disputes: disagreements about the amount of compensation due to a party for the use of their land or for any harm caused to their land.

Consequences of Land Disputes:

Land disputes can have significant consequences for individuals and communities, including:

• Loss of land: One party may lose their right to use or own land.
• Financial losses: Parties may incur legal costs and other expenses related to resolving the dispute.
• Social conflict: Land disputes can lead to tension and conflict between communities or individuals.
• Delayed development: Land disputes can impede land use and development projects.

Resolving Land Disputes:

There are various ways to resolve land disputes, including:

• Mediation: A neutral third party helps the parties reach a mutually agreeable solution.
• Arbitration: An independent arbitrator hears the case and makes a binding decision.
• Litigation: The parties present their case to a court of law, which will issue a final judgment.

Importance of Understanding Land Disputes:

Understanding the definition, types, and consequences of land disputes is crucial for:

• Individuals: Protecting their land rights and interests.
• Communities: Promoting peace and stability.
• Government: Developing effective policies and programs to manage land use and resolve land disputes.

What are land disputes?

Characteristics and causes of land disputes

Legal Basis:

• 2013 Land Law of Vietnam
• Circular No. 14/2012/TT-BTNMT

Causes of Land Disputes:

Subjective Reasons:

• Deficiencies in state land management:
  • Lack of strictness in enforcement.
  • Limited decentralization and assignment of responsibilities.
  • Insufficient qualifications of officials.
• Unclear land management planning:
  • Messy land use planning.
  • Unreasonable land use purposes.
  • Unclear legal documents.
• Ineffective leadership and direction of officials.

Objective Reasons:

• Increased land value:
  • Land as a highly valuable asset.
  • Greed and disregard for disputes for personal gain.

Characteristics and causes of land disputes

Characteristics of Land Disputes:

1. Subjects:

• Individuals, households, or organizations with land use rights.
• Land rights established through allocation, lease, or state permission/recognition of transfer.
• Disputes occur when rights are violated and subjects have conflicting claims.

2. Object:

• Land use rights and management rights.
• Focus on the right to use and manage a specific area of land.
• Only disputes involving these rights are considered land disputes.

3. Content:

• Diverse and complex, involving various issues:
  • Land area.
  • Use rights.
  • Land use purposes.
  • Related civil transactions.

4. Relationship:

• Distinct from other disputes:
  • Disputes between land users and authorities are considered administrative complaints, not land disputes.

5. Impact:

• Affects direct rights and interests of parties involved.
• Impairs the ability of parties to fulfill obligations to the State.
• Requires quick, active, and proactive resolution to protect all interests involved.

Summary:

Understanding the legal basis, causes, and characteristics of land disputes is crucial for various stakeholders:

• Individuals: Protects their land rights and interests.
• Communities: Promotes peace and stability.
• Government: Develops effective land management policies and resolves disputes efficiently.

Note:

This information provides a general overview. Specific details and legal nuances may vary depending on the individual case and applicable regulations.

Why understanding land disputes is important

Legal Basis:

• Resolution 04/2017/NQ-HDTP: Regulates the procedures for resolving land disputes.
• Circular 33/2017/TT-BTNMT: Defines the circumstances under which a Red Book application can be refused.
• 2013 Land Law: Establishes the legal framework for land ownership and use rights.

Reasons for Importance:

• Protecting individual rights: Understanding the legal procedures for resolving land disputes empowers individuals to defend their land rights and interests against potential violations or improper application of laws by authorities.
• Ensuring fair and efficient dispute resolution: Knowledge of available options and regulations helps individuals choose the appropriate forum (conciliation, court, People’s Committee) for resolving their dispute effectively and expeditiously.
• Preventing wrongful denial of Red Book applications: Understanding the grounds for refusal allows individuals to ensure their applications meet all legal requirements and prevent unjustified delays or denials.
• Promoting transparency and accountability: By understanding the legal framework, individuals can hold authorities accountable for their actions and advocate for transparent and fair land management practices.
• Maintaining social stability: Unresolved land disputes can lead to social unrest and conflict. Understanding the legal system and available solutions fosters a peaceful and stable society.

Why understanding land disputes is important

Specific Examples:

• Conciliation requirement: Individuals must attempt conciliation at the local commune, ward, or town level before filing a lawsuit or requesting intervention from higher authorities. Understanding this requirement ensures individuals follow the proper procedure and avoid potential delays or invalid claims.
• Red Book application refusal: Knowing that a Red Book application can be refused if a dispute over the land exists motivates individuals to resolve any outstanding issues before applying. This promotes responsible land use and minimizes potential conflicts.
• Choice of dispute resolution forum: Depending on the nature of the dispute and whether the individual possesses a Red Book, understanding the available options (court, People’s Committee) helps them choose the most efficient and effective path to resolution.

Conclusion:

Understanding land disputes equips individuals with the knowledge and tools necessary to protect their land rights, navigate the legal system effectively, and contribute to a just and stable society.

Choosing how to settle disputes is an option

The jurisdiction of settling land disputes

Legal Basis:

• 2013 Land Law: Article 203 defines the jurisdiction for resolving land disputes.
• Circular 33/2017/TT-BTNMT: Specifies conditions for refusal of Red Book applications related to land disputes.
• Resolution 04/2017/NQ-HDTP of the Justice Council: Regulates procedures for resolving land disputes.

The jurisdiction of settling land disputes

Jurisdiction:

• Conciliation:
  • Initial stage: Land disputes must first be conciliated at the commune-level People’s Committee where the land is located.
  • Unsuccessful conciliation: If the conciliation fails, the dispute will be further resolved based on the following factors:
• Holding a Certificate or Article 100 documents:
  • Disputes involving assets attached to land: These will be resolved by the People’s Court.
• No Certificate or Article 100 documents:
  • The litigant can choose one of two options:
    • Submit a request to the People’s Committee: This applies to disputes over land use rights, land acquisition, land allocation, land lease, and land recovery.
    • Initiate a lawsuit at the People’s Court: This applies to disputes over land inheritance, transactions involving land use rights (conversion, transfer, mortgage, donation, subleasing, capital contribution), and division of land use rights as common property of spouses.

Additional Points:

• The People’s Committee at the district or provincial level has jurisdiction depending on the subject of the dispute.
• Land disputes with foreign elements may require different jurisdictional considerations.
• Individuals are encouraged to seek legal advice to determine the appropriate forum and procedures for resolving their land dispute.

Benefits of Understanding Jurisdiction:

• Ensures proper and efficient dispute resolution.
• Protects individual rights and interests.
• Promotes transparency and accountability in land management.
• Contributes to social stability by preventing prolonged and unresolved disputes.

Conclusion:

Understanding the legal framework for land dispute resolution is essential for individuals and organizations to protect their land rights and access appropriate legal remedies.

The types of land disputes

Legal Basis:

• 2013 Land Law of Vietnam
• Resolution 04/2017/NQ-HDTP
• Civil Code of Vietnam

Case 1: Land Use Rights Dispute:

• Definition: Disputes about who has the legal right to use a specific piece of land.
• Examples:
  • Duplicate land allocations.
  • Boundary disputes between adjacent plots.
  • Land encroachment.
  • Disputes over mortgages or paths related to land.
• Focus: Determining the rightful owner of land use rights.

Case 2: Rights and Obligations during Land Use:

• Definition: Disputes arising from civil transactions involving land use rights.
• Examples:
  • Conversion of land use rights.
  • Transfer of land use rights.
  • Sublease of land use rights.
  • Mortgage of land use rights.
  • Contribution of land use rights as capital.
• Focus: Resolving issues related to contractual agreements on land use.

The types of land disputes

Case 3: Inheritance of Land Use Rights:

• Definition: Disputes arising during the inheritance of land use rights.
• Examples:
  • Division of inheritance according to law.
  • Disputes between heirs regarding land use rights.
• Focus: Determining the rightful inheritors and their respective shares of land use rights.

Case 4: Disputes over Assets Attached to Land Use Rights:

• Definition: Disputes about assets attached to land, such as houses, trees, fences, or structures.
• Examples:
  • Disputes over ownership of buildings on assigned land.
  • Conflicts regarding shared resources attached to the land.
• Focus: Determining who has the right to use and manage these attached assets.

Additional Notes:

• This categorization is not exhaustive and other types of land disputes may exist.
• The specific legal basis and procedures for resolving each type of dispute may vary depending on the circumstances.
• Consulting legal professionals is recommended for complex cases or disputes involving significant value.

Importance of Understanding Land Dispute Types:

• Helps individuals identify the nature of their land dispute.
• Provides guidance on the appropriate legal framework and procedures for resolution.
• Facilitates communication and negotiation with other parties involved in the dispute.
• Increases the chances of achieving a fair and timely resolution.

Conclusion:

Understanding the different types of land disputes empowers individuals to navigate complex legal issues and protect their land rights effectively.

Documents needed to file a lawsuit in a land dispute

Legal Basis:

• 2013 Land Law: Article 203 defines the jurisdiction for resolving land disputes.
• Circular 33/2017/TT-BTNMT: Specifies conditions for refusal of Red Book applications related to land disputes.
• Resolution 04/2017/NQ-HDTP: Regulates procedures for resolving land disputes.
• Civil Procedure Code of Vietnam: Establishes the general framework for filing lawsuits.

Required Documents:

1. Petition:

   • Drafted correctly and with complete content according to Form No. 23 – DS.
   • Must clearly state the following information:
     • Parties involved in the dispute (plaintiff, defendant).
     • Nature of the land dispute.
     • Requested solution.
     • Supporting evidence and arguments.
   • Must be signed and dated by the plaintiff.

2. Certificate of Land Use Rights (Red Book) or Alternative Document:

   • One of the documents specified in Article 100 of the 2013 Land Law.
   • Proof of ownership or legal interest in the land.

3. Minutes of Conciliation:

   • Evidence of attempted conciliation at the commune-level People’s Committee.
   • Required for disputes not resolved through conciliation.

4. Identity Card or Citizen Identification Card (copy):

   • Identification of the plaintiff.

5. Household Registration Book (copy):

   • Verification of residency and relationship to the land.

6. Other Related Documents:

   • Any additional evidence relevant to the land dispute.
   • May include contracts, agreements, surveys, witness statements, etc.

Land Disputes Lawsuit

Documents Needed to File a Land Dispute Lawsuit: Legal Basis and Details

Legal Basis:

• 2013 Land Law: Article 203 defines the jurisdiction for resolving land disputes.
• Circular 33/2017/TT-BTNMT: Specifies conditions for refusal of Red Book applications related to land disputes.
• Resolution 04/2017/NQ-HDTP: Regulates procedures for resolving land disputes.
• Civil Procedure Code of Vietnam: Establishes the general framework for filing lawsuits.

Required Documents:

1. Petition:

   • Drafted correctly and with complete content according to Form No. 23 – DS.
   • Must clearly state the following information:
     • Parties involved in the dispute (plaintiff, defendant).
     • Nature of the land dispute.
     • Requested solution.
     • Supporting evidence and arguments.
   • Must be signed and dated by the plaintiff.

2. Certificate of Land Use Rights (Red Book) or Alternative Document:

   • One of the documents specified in Article 100 of the 2013 Land Law.
   • Proof of ownership or legal interest in the land.

3. Minutes of Conciliation:

   • Evidence of attempted conciliation at the commune-level People’s Committee.
   • Required for disputes not resolved through conciliation.

4. Identity Card or Citizen Identification Card (copy):

   • Identification of the plaintiff.

5. Household Registration Book (copy):

   • Verification of residency and relationship to the land.

6. Other Related Documents:

   • Any additional evidence relevant to the land dispute.
   • May include contracts, agreements, surveys, witness statements, etc.

Importance of Complete Documentation:

• Ensures the lawsuit is accepted and processed by the Court.
• Provides the Court with necessary information to understand the dispute.
• Increases the likelihood of a favorable outcome for the plaintiff.

Recommendations:

• Seek legal advice to ensure proper document preparation and filing procedures.
• Review the Civil Procedure Code and relevant legal provisions for specific requirements.
• Submit all required documents in a timely manner.

Conclusion:

Filing a land dispute lawsuit requires careful preparation and attention to detail. Understanding the legal basis and required documents empowers individuals to navigate the legal system and effectively defend their land rights.

NT International Law Firm has addressed the question of what land disputes are and how to settle them. If you have any further questions or concerns regarding land or real estate, please contact our law firm immediately for expert legal advice.

If you require any legal assistance, please feel free to reach out to us via phone at 090 252 4567 or through email: info@ntpartnerlawfirm.com. At NT INTERNATIONAL LAW FIRM, our team is committed to offering you prompt and personalized advice.

You also might be interested in: The 2013 Law on Land